May 28, 2013; Los Angeles, CA, USA; Los Angeles Kings right wing Dustin Brown (23) is knocked down by San Jose Sharks defenseman Brad Stuart (7) in the third period of game seven of the second round of the 2013 Stanley Cup Playoffs at the Staples Center. Mandatory Credit: Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY Sports

Your Call : Brad Stuart Suspension - Thomas Hertl Goal

Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

With the New York Islanders preparing to travel for a tough weekend road trip, news around Long Island has been quiet today. But that does not mean it has been for the rest of the National Hockey League.

After only a week in, we are dealing with some controversy surrounding the San Jose Sharks 9-2 drubbing of the New York Rangers on Tuesday night in San Jose.

Brad Stuart and Thomas Hertl were the primary ring-leaders in the rout and some around the league and rival fan-bases are already making their voices heard.

In case you have been living under a rock, the Sharks scored 7 times over the final 40 minutes and out-shot the Rangers 47-20 in driving star goaltender Henrik Lundqvist to the bench and causing many in the Rangers supporters section to over-react on social media, declaring their season over after only 3 games (which, of course, is very pre-mature).

First, Brad Stuart, defenseman for the Sharks had this run in with New York star Rick Nash along the near boards.

While, initially, the hit looks clean, you can clearly see that Stuart targeted the head on the similar sized Nash, and that is a huge no-no in today’s NHL. The league ruled hard in this case, giving Stuart a three game suspension for his actions.

Did the hit deserve a suspension? By new standards and rules, yes it did. But at the same time, and this is by no means giving any justification, Nash got away with a Tito Santana style flying elbow last year with hardly a call from the league office.

What it does show is another example of the inconsistency in handing out these types of punishments by the league’s head of discipline, Brendan Shanahan. And it was clearly preceded by the man he replaced, Colin Campbell…..

You make the call. Did Stuart deserve his 3 game suspension?

Loading ... Loading ...


The second incident involved San Jose’s dynamic 19 year old rookie. With his team up 7-2 and 8 minutes remaining in the third period this happened…..

The goal was clearly remarkable and brought fans out of their seats. But was it necessary? Thomas Hertl skated in like running a practice drill and just totally embarrassed the Rangers team and goaltender Martin Biron.

The Rangers did not react at all to this goal in any shape or form, just like they did not avenge the Nash hit on the ice. Should they have? Putting all your fandom aside for a second and thinking like a hockey fan, let us know….

You make the call. Hertl goal....over the line?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...



Next Islanders Game Full schedule »
Saturday, Nov 11 Nov7:30at San Jose SharksBuy Tickets

Tags: Brad Stuart New York Islanders Nhl Puck Drop Rick Nash Thomas Hertl

comments powered by Disqus