4. Bryan Trottier
Aside from that disastrous idea to coach in the city for a season (which both the Rangers and Islanders would never like to bring up ever again), Bryan Trottier is one of the more revered Islanders in history. He ranks first in games played with 1,123, first in points with 1,353, and second in goals with a nice round number of 500.
Next: Number 3