Chicago Blackhawks | Steve Thomas
In 79 games during the 1992-93 season, Thomas scored 37 goals and 87 points. In total, he’d play 275 games and score 258 points for the Isles.
Honorable mention: Nick Leddy
Colorado Avalanche: Wendel Clark
I didn’t count trades with the Colorado Rockies because they aren’t currently in the NHL. Otherwise, Pat LaFontaine would have easily been the player here.
The Isles picked up Wendel Clark from the Avalanche for Claude Lemieux who they had just picked up from the New Jersey Devils with Steve Thomas going the other way.
Clark would play 58 games and score 43 points before being traded back to Toronto in that six-player swap that gave the Isles Kenny Jonsson and the pick that would be used to draft Roberto Luongo.
Dallas Stars: 2006 2nd (Jesse Joensuu)
There haven’t been many deals between these two teams. On five occasions the Stars and Islanders have made a trade. I’m not counting deals done with the Minnesota North Stars.
Over four seasons, Joensuu played 67 games and scored 15 points. Erskine would play 34 games for the Isles scoring a single point.
Minnesota Wild: 2009 1st (Calvin de Haan)
At the 2009 draft, the Islanders moved up four spots to 12th overall by sending the 16th, 77th, and 181st overall pick to the Wild. Garth Snow used that 12th overall pick to take Calvin de Haan.
Calvin de Haan was a good top-four defender for the Isles playing 304 games over six seasons.
Nashville Predators: 2008 1st (Josh Bailey)
The Isles moved down twice in the 2008 draft. The first time was from fifth to seventh in a trade with the Toronto Maple Leafs. The second time was from seventh to eighth in a deal with the Nashville Predators.
With the eighth overall pick, the Islanders selected Josh Bailey. Since 2008, Bailey has played 865 games. That makes Bailey the fifth longest-tenured Islander in franchise history, and with another four years on his contract, Bailey could overtake current franchise leader Bryan Trottier (1,123 GP).
St Louis Blues: Brian Lavender
In 1972, the Islanders picked up Brian Lavender in a cash transaction with the Blues. Lavender would play 43 games with the Islanders before being sent to Detroit in a four-player deal four months later.
Winnipeg Jets: N/A
The Islanders have never made a trade with the current edition of the Winnipeg Jets.