3 reasons why it's good that NY Islanders D Matthew Schaefer didn't make Team Canada

This might sound backwards at first, especially when you’re talking about an 18-year-old defenseman who looks like a future superstar. But the more I think about it, the more convinced I am that Matthew Schaefer not making Team Canada for the 2026 Olympics is actually a good thing — for him, and for the New York Islanders.

"He's a fantastic talent. He brings you out of your seat every night, said Team Canada GM Doug Armstrong. "He's got maturity beyond his years on and off the ice. I was shocked by how quickly he worked his way into our conversations, and that's a credit to him. The Islanders are very lucky and hockey is very lucky to have a young player like him coming onto the horizon."

There’s no rush. His time is absolutely coming

Schaefer is 18. Let that sink in. He’s already logging top-pair minutes in the NHL, driving play, and commanding respect from veterans around the league. Missing this Olympic cycle doesn’t close a door — it simply delays it. Defensemen, especially elite ones, often peak later than forwards. By the time the next Olympics roll around, Schaefer won’t be fighting for a spot; he’ll be expecting one. There’s value in letting greatness arrive naturally instead of forcing it early.

Fewer miles, fewer risks, more development

The Olympic stage is incredible, but it’s also unforgiving. Extra games, extra travel, unfamiliar systems, and the emotional weight of representing your country can take a toll — especially on a teenager already handling massive NHL responsibilities. The Islanders are asking Schaefer to be the guy on their blue line right now. Staying put means more rest, more practice time, and more controlled development in a system designed specifically for him.

Future Motivator

If you don’t think this sticks with him, you don’t know competitors. Being left off Team Canada isn’t going to discourage Schaefer — it’s going to fuel him. Every great player has a moment like this early in their career. Something they remember. Something they use. This is how edge is built. This is how confidence hardens. When Schaefer eventually pulls on that maple leaf, he’ll do it knowing he earned it, not because of projection or hype.

So yes, it would’ve been cool to see him on the Olympic stage. But sometimes the best thing for a generational player — and for the Islanders — is patience. And in this case, patience feels like the right call.