Matthew Schaefer’s latest performance requires more than a glance at the scoresheet. It requires a trip through the New York Islanders’ record book.
After his first NHL hat trick in Tuesday’s 5-1 victory over Columbus, the 19-year-old is sharing statistical company with franchise greats and approaching milestones few teenage defensemen have reached.
Courtesy of Eric Hornick’s The Skinny, here is where Schaefer’s remarkable run stands.
His three goals put him alongside Denis Potvin and Jean Potvin as the only Isles defensemen with a hat trick. At 19 years, 73 days, Schaefer became the youngest defenseman in franchise history to accomplish it. Only Phil Housley did so at a younger age among NHL defensemen.
A night to remember for Schaef!
— New York Islanders (@NYIslanders) November 18, 2026
🧢🧢🧢 pic.twitter.com/k2Gwa5OVep
Schaefer also became the fourth Isles teenager with a hat trick, joining Pat LaFontaine, Bryan Trottier and Brent Sutter. Only LaFontaine was younger.
The goals raised Schaefer’s career total to 32, matching Trottier’s franchise record for teenagers. His sixth career game-winning goal moved him past Trottier for the teenage club record.
The production extends beyond scoring. Schaefer has consecutive three-point games, becoming the first Isles defenseman to do that since Vladimir Malakhov in 1993 and the youngest defenseman in NHL history.
His 83 career points leave him one behind Rasmus Dahlin for second among teenage NHL defensemen. Housley’s record remains 49 points away.
Schaefer has recorded a point in 12 of his past 13 games; the Isles were shut out in the exception. His current six-game point streak matches his career best and is already his second such streak this season.
All nine of his goals this season have come within 11 games, a burst last achieved by an Isles defenseman when Adrian Aucoin did it in 2004.
And after going without a shot Saturday, Schaefer matched his career high with nine Tuesday.
The records keep coming. So does Schaefer.
