Eight rounds. That's how long it took at SAP Center on November 9 before anyone scored in the shootout, and it wasn't an Islander. Ivar Stenberg, who'd also scored in regulation, beat Ilya Sorokin over the glove, while Yaroslav Askarov made 30 saves and stopped all eight Islander shooters. Sorokin's 37 saves earned only a single point from a 3-2 loss, as the Sharks ended a five-game losing streak.
Twice the Islanders led, through Ben Hutton's first goal as an Islander and Victor Eklund's power-play strike 71 seconds into the second. Twice they were pegged back, the second time when Tyler Toffoli's shot deflected off Adam Pelech at 12:12 of the second. Then nothing, through the third and overtime.
Islanders' recent woes
That result left the Islanders at 7-6-4, winless in four games (0-2-2) and without a regulation win in eight straight. A 4-0 home defeat to Edmonton and a 5-3 loss to Carolina were followed by a 5-4 overtime loss to New Jersey and the shootout in San Jose. The road trip has since turned, with a 5-2 win over the Kings on November 12 and a 6-2 win over the Ducks two nights later lifting New York to 9-6-4 and a four-game point streak. In both wins, though, the Islanders scored first, and online betting sites have taken note of what happens when they don't.
The latest hockey odds still reflect doubts about whether the Islanders can reach the playoffs for the first time since 2024. One statistic underscores those doubts: The Islanders rarely mount comebacks of any kind.
The Islanders are 8-0-3 when they score first and 1-6-1 when they concede the opening goal. They have one come-from-behind win all season, none when trailing in the third period, and no multi-goal third-period comeback wins. On November 5, they fought back from 2-0 and 3-2 down against the defending Stanley Cup champion Hurricanes, only for William Carrier to bury a rebound with 5:08 left in a 5-3 defeat. They have proven that they can claw level, but they can't then go on and finish the job. And here's why.
Power play vanishes when it's needed the most
Chasing a game usually means leaning on the man advantage, and this one has stopped delivering. Before their November 12 game in Los Angeles, the Islanders were 2-for-22 on the power play over their last seven games and 4-for-36 over their last 12. They went 0-for-4 against Carolina after entering that night 29th in the league, and analysis from Yardbarker argued afterwards that the power play remains a main reason the team so often fails to close out games.
Even the good news carries an asterisk. The power play has now scored in three straight road games, through Eklund in San Jose, Matthew Schaefer in Los Angeles and Bo Horvat in Anaheim, but none of those goals came from behind. Eklund's and Schaefer's broke ties, and Horvat's stretched a 1-0 lead. Entering the Anaheim game, the unit still ranked 28th in the league at 16.4%. None of this is new, either.
The unit finished 30th in the NHL last season and 31st at 12.6% in 2024-25, the lowest mark in franchise history since the stat became official in 1977-78.
Third periods belong to the opposition
Most comebacks are built in the last 20 minutes, which is precisely where the Islanders run out of steam. Through 19 games, they've outscored opponents 27-19 in second periods but been outscored 17-13 in thirds, and they haven't won a single game after trailing in the final frame.
Against Carolina, the 3-3 tie held until Carrier struck with 5:08 left, and Jalen Chatfield's empty-netter closed it out; the Islanders managed just one scoring chance at 5-on-5 in that third period. Two nights later, the Devils erased a two-goal third-period deficit and won it in overtime. In San Jose, nobody scored after the second intermission at all. Instead of pressing late, they're the team being pressed.
Creators on the sidelines
Where did the next goal come from when Mathew Barzal, Matias Maccelli and Calum Ritchie were all out of the lineup? Barzal missed the first 18 games because of left-knee inflammation before making his season debut in Anaheim on November 14, when he played 16:21 and assisted on Ben Hutton's opening goal. Maccelli and Ritchie were both hurt in the first period of the 4-1 win over Toronto on October 17, with Maccelli given a two-to-four-week timeline and Ritchie four to six.
Maccelli, signed as a free agent in the summer, had two goals and four assists in eight games before the injury, working the left half-wall on a top power-play unit that was humming early. He returned in Los Angeles on November 12 and has three assists in two games since, while Ritchie remains on injured reserve.
These are the players who make something from nothing when a team is chasing. Without them, the lineup leaned on depth forwards and young players asked to do too much. The Islanders have not trailed at any point in the two games since Maccelli's return, so the real test of the healthier lineup in a comeback situation is still to come. Jean-Gabriel Pageau, meanwhile, has missed the last two games with a lower-body injury and is day-to-day.
Thin blue line that keeps going to the box
Consider what it took for Schaefer, 19, to log a team-high 30:51 in San Jose. It was his fourth game of 30-plus minutes in about two weeks, after 32:16 at Nashville, 30:01 at Minnesota and 30:01 against Carolina. Alexander Romanov tore his ACL against the Rangers on October 6 and is expected to miss six to eight months, while Ryan Pulock missed four games after getting hurt at Minnesota. How do you push in the third when your best defenseman has already logged half the game? Pulock's return in Los Angeles cut Schaefer's workload to 27:02, but Logan Stanley left the Anaheim game in the second period with a lower-body injury.
Make no mistake, that's a tax on any late push, and discipline compounds it. Against Edmonton, Emil Heineman was ejected at 2:22 for a knee-on-knee hit, and Pete DeBoer called the miscues, including three second-period penalties and a 10-minute misconduct to Scott Mayfield, "self-inflicted." In San Jose, Ondrej Palat and Anthony Duclair were penalized during Mason Marchment's double minor, handing the Sharks a 4-on-3.
Every minute spent killing a penalty is a minute not spent chasing the game. And as long as that continues, the third-period heroics will be saved for whoever the Islanders are facing, rather than the Islanders themselves.
