Matthew Schaefer named CHL Top Prospect as NY Islanders draft decision nears

The New York Islanders' scouting department is carefully evaluating its options as the team prepares for the 2025 NHL Draft, where they hold the No. 1 overall pick. While several talented prospects are in the conversation, the consensus across the league, including from NHL Central Scouting, is that Matthew Schaefer is the top choice.

A 17-year-old defenseman from the Erie Otters, Schaefer has firmly established himself as the premier prospect in this year’s draft class. Earlier this week, he was honored with the CHL Top Draft Prospect Award and secured the No. 1 ranking among North American skaters from NHL Central Scouting. Schaefer’s impact on the ice this season was undeniable, despite a shortened campaign due to injury. In just 17 games, he recorded 22 points (7 goals, 15 assists) and posted a remarkable +21 rating. His performance was a testament to his elite skill set, including his superior skating, hockey IQ, and two-way ability.

Schaefer’s leadership abilities were also on full display as he captained Team Canada to a gold medal at the 2024 Hlinka Gretzky Cup and represented his country at the 2025 IIHF World Junior Championship. Unfortunately, his tournament was cut short by a clavicle injury, but his composure and maturity under pressure only enhanced his standing as a future NHL star.

Off the ice, Schaefer has faced profound personal challenges, including the loss of both his mother and his billet mother. Rather than allowing these tragedies to hinder his growth, Schaefer turned adversity into strength, channeling his grief into his on-ice performance. His resilience and mental toughness beyond his years speak to his character and potential as a leader at the highest level.

For the Islanders, Schaefer represents more than just a top-tier defenseman. His combination of speed, vision, and defensive acumen makes him an ideal candidate to anchor the team’s blue line for years to come. As the draft draws near, the Islanders are presented with a transformative opportunity to select a player capable of not only enhancing their defensive core but also serving as a cornerstone for sustained success. Schaefer's skill, leadership, and resilience align perfectly with the Islanders’ goals of returning to championship contention. With the No. 1 pick, selecting Schaefer could mark the beginning of a new era for the franchise.