Skip to main content

Matthew Schaefer’s NY Islanders teammates sound off on what they have been witnessing

ByMichael Stahurski
Columbus Blue Jackets v New York Islanders
Columbus Blue Jackets v New York Islanders | Steven Ryan/GettyImages

We are witnessing greatness every time Matthew Schaefer takes the ice. For a player who wasn’t the consensus first overall pick entering draft night in 2025, Schaefer has taken the league by storm.

With a record being broken seemingly every night, Schaefer became only the third NY Islanders defenseman to record a hat trick, joining Jean and Denis Potvin, and the first since Denis’ in 1982.

It's been a joy to watch him play, and even his teammates recognize what he's accomplishing at just 19 years old.

“We’re watching greatness,” Mat Barzal said following Tuesday night's performance. “If there was a question about the Norris, he's got to be right there if not the front runner. It's pretty special. It's fun to watch, that's for sure.

When Barzal entered the league in 2018, he was garnering some of the same recognition, and now he has a front-row seat to watch Schaefer do something similar.

“He's in a different class of his own,” Anthony Duclair said. “I haven't seen a young defensman come in the league as he did and just fly around. He's so dominant every single night, so I haven't seen that type of player in my career to be honest.”

Duclair, who has spent time with nine different organizations, has played alongside some of the league's best players, andut even he can see there is something different in the way Schaefer plays the game.

“He’s obviously a special player,” Bo Horvat said on NHL Tonight. “He’s such a special player for so many reasons. Not only offensively but for what he’s doing but defensively as well playing against the other teams' top lines every night. He’s just a difference maker. He’s a generational talent.”

Horvat and Schaefer have been the Islanders top performers this season, keeping the team in the thick of things despite all of the number of injuries the islanders have endured.

Add us as a preferred source on Google