New York Islanders stuck in limbo at trade deadline

The New York Islanders are stuck in limbo at this year’s trade deadline. While they rode into the 4 Nations Face-Off break playing some of their best hockey of the season, they’re still out of a playoff spot. While still within striking distance, the Isles aren’t quite on the cusp of getting into a spot.

At the same time, the Isles aren’t bad enough to be a lottery-pick team this season. They can still turn up the heat and play far better than teams like the Anaheim Ducks, San Jose Sharks, or Montreal Canadiens. That situation puts the New York Islanders in limbo.

Earlier this season, I called for the Isles to be sellers. They were on the ropes and seemingly ready to hit the floor. But the Isles have been resilient and pulled together a seven-game winning streak to get back into the playoff picture.

That has prompted many, including myself, to rein in talk of selling at the trade deadline. But does that mean the Islanders should be buyers now? Honestly, it’s a tough question to answer. In my estimation, the Isles’ trade deadline approach should be based on what’s available in the market.

If the Islanders can make a solid move to help the club, they should be buyers. But if the market tilts toward selling at a higher-than-expected price, they should lean toward selling. The Isles could have a chance to shed pieces and retool with next year in mind.

Selling might seem like they’re giving up, but that’s something the Isles must consider, especially if the club cannot sustain its success coming out of the 4 Nations break.

The worst thing New York Islanders can do is nothing

The worst thing the New York Islanders can do at this trade deadline is nothing. While standing pat may signal that management believes in this roster, it would be foolish not to buy or sell. If management sits on its hands, they risk losing valuable assets for nothing.

Unless the Isles already have deals in place for Brock Nelson and Kyle Palmieri, the best thing to do is focus on re-signing or trading these impending free agents.

Additionally, the Isles have to get real with their commitment to the future. If the club is staring at a rebuild, then this trade deadline should reflect that approach. Conversely, if the club feels there’s an opportunity for contention, the deadline moves should go toward adding useful pieces.

By doing nothing, the Islanders essentially let an opportunity walk out the door. The opportunity is lost in either rebuilding or bolstering the lineup. The cost of doing nothing could be much higher than that of actually making a move.

There is a growing sense of urgency as the stretch run to this season is fast approaching. The season is almost three-quarters of the way done. The time to act is now.