Every Simon Holmstrom goal gives New York Islanders fans another reason to celebrate. It also gives Mathieu Darche another reason to wonder what a long-term contract might have cost in July 2025.
The two-year, $7.25 million agreement looked sensible then. Holmstrom received a raise, and the Isles avoided committing significant term after one breakout season. At a $3.625 million annual cap hit, he remains affordable.
But affordable now could mean expensive later.
Saturday’s first career hat trick against Anaheim offered another reminder of the offensive ability the Isles risked undervaluing. Holmstrom already had a 20-goal, 45-point season before signing that bridge deal. There was evidence worth betting on, even if there were questions about whether he could sustain it.
Darche chose to wait for more certainty. Certainty usually costs extra.
The timing makes that decision particularly uncomfortable. Holmstrom’s contract expires after this season, when he will remain a restricted free agent. That gives the Isles negotiating leverage, but it does not freeze his value at yesterday’s prices.
FIRST CAREER NHL HAT TRICK SIMON HOLMSTROM 🎩
— Gino Hard (@GinoHard_) November 15, 2026
And the Isles lead 6-2!! 😯 pic.twitter.com/O4Nrta6TNL
The NHL’s salary cap is $104 million this season, with $113.5 million scheduled for 2027-28. The league has also provided a preliminary $127.5 million estimate for 2028-29, although discussions could alter how those increases are distributed. More spending room means a richer negotiating environment for productive players entering their prime.
A longer agreement in 2025 could have secured Holmstrom’s development years before that inflation accelerated.
There is a caveat: We do not know whether Holmstrom would have accepted the term or price that made sense for Darche. A general manager cannot sign both sides of a contract.
Still, the missed opportunity is becoming harder to ignore.
One hat trick does not establish his next salary. Sustained production will. If Holmstrom keeps delivering, the Isles will pay for the improvement and for waiting to believe in it.
