Patrick Roy should be on hot seat if NY Islanders complete playoff collapse

The New York Islanders were never supposed to be here.

This was meant to be a transition year — a season where expectations were tempered, development took priority, and the playoffs were more hope than requirement. A fanbase ready to embrace a retool understood the bigger picture.

Then everything changed.

Behind the brilliance of Matthew Schaefer, elite goaltending from Ilya Sorokin, and clutch O.T. moments from Bo Horvat, Mathew Barzal, JG Pageau, and others, the Islanders didn’t just stay competitive — they surged into a playoff position. And with that, expectations shifted in real time.

When general manager Mathieu Darche dealt a significant package, including their first-round pick from Colorado, to acquire Brayden Schenn from St. Louis, it was a clear signal: this was no longer a developmental year. This was a team expected to make the postseason.

Now, that bet is under scrutiny.

Following a fourth straight loss Saturday night — another game defined by lapses in effort and execution — the Islanders are trending in the wrong direction at the worst possible time. What once looked like a bold, rewarding move for a deserving locker room is now in danger of being viewed as premature, even reckless.

The standings haven’t buried them yet. Other teams stumbling has kept the door open. But the margin is razor thin, and the Islanders look like a team searching for answers rather than asserting control.

That’s where Patrick Roy enters the conversation.

“We’re right there. We’re right there in the standings,” Roy said after the 4-3 loss in Carolina. “It’s not the time of year we can feel sorry for ourselves. You have to go out there and play, focus on the next game.”

Roy deserves credit for instilling confidence and helping guide this team into relevance sooner than expected. But in the NHL, expectations evolve — and accountability follows.

If the Islanders fall short, the narrative will be unavoidable: a team that raised the bar, made a win-now move, and failed to deliver when it mattered most. Roy shouldered the blame for the team's recent slow starts and understands that, as head coach, he is ultimately responsible.

For Roy, that could mean entering next season with real pressure — or worse, uncertainty about his future behind the bench.

It's obvious what needs to happen to change the story. A late surge, a playoff berth, and the gamble pays off. But if the Islanders stumble to the finish line, the questions will be loud.

And fair.

Because once expectations change, there are ramifications when you come up short.