Casey Cizikas Is a Plus for the New York Islanders’ Heart and Soul

MINUS

Like all players, Cizikas is not without his flaws. Despite his courage and dedication to the game, he’s a depth player. As such, the New York Islanders shouldn’t expect Cizikas to carry the team on his back and lead them to a Stanley Cup in the way Mario Lemieux, Sidney Crosby, or Alex Ovechkin have.

Then again, the Isles don’t need Cizikas to do that. Therefore, whatever offensive shortcomings Cizikas may show can be overcome by the high-end talent in the club’s top six.

It’s also worth pointing out that Cizikas is getting older. He’s 33 and not getting any younger. As such, questions have emerged about how much longer he can keep up the style of play he’s shown over the years.

While he could remain a highly physical player for the foreseeable future, there is no telling when injuries may take their toll. If that’s the case, the Isles may need to find a replacement for him on the checking line.

Lastly, Cizikas is in the middle of a six-year deal that carries a $2.5 million cap hit, according to PuckPedia. Now, the contract itself isn’t bad. Some may argue that it’s high for a depth player. But given Cizikas’ spiritual value to the team, the hit is justifiable.

The concern may be that with other young players in need of new contracts, such as Noah Dobson, Cizikas’ cap hit may become somewhat of an obstacle. In that situation, would the Isles consider moving Cizikas?

Let’s assume that Cizikas’ contract never becomes an issue. In that case, does the club re-sign him in 2027 when he becomes a free agent? Perhaps he signs a league-minimum deal just to stay in New York for the rest of his career.

Nevertheless, questions may emerge about Cizikas’ effectiveness and productivity as he gets older.

The Verdict

The New York Islanders cannot part ways with Cizikas as long as he can play. While he may lose some of his signature style as he gets older, the Isles cannot afford to kick him to the curb. The New York Islanders must do everything in their power to ensure Casey Cizikas rides off into the sunset after a long and productive career.