Skip to main content

The Islanders have only one path to the playoffs in 2026-27

The New York Islanders have one clear path to the 2027 NHL playoffs, amid a truly tough road in the Eastern Conference.
ByNestor Quixtan
Apr 9, 2026; Elmont, New York, USA;  New York Islanders head coach Peter DeBoer speaks to the press following the team’s 5-3 win over the Toronto Maple Leafs at UBS Arena. Mandatory Credit: Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images
Apr 9, 2026; Elmont, New York, USA; New York Islanders head coach Peter DeBoer speaks to the press following the team’s 5-3 win over the Toronto Maple Leafs at UBS Arena. Mandatory Credit: Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The New York Islanders have had their ups and downs this season. But after Matthew Schaefer torched the Columbus Blue Jackets on Tuesday night, things are starting to look much better on the island.

The Isles are 10-6-4, good for 20 points, and four points behind the crosstown rival New York Rangers for third in the Metro Division.

And that’s precisely the path that the Islanders have to the playoffs in 2026-27.

The other potential paths to a playoff spot look much more daunting at this point.

So, let’s start with the Metro Division.

Islanders’ best chance at the playoffs is third in the Metro Division

Third place in the Metro is really the only realistic path to the playoffs. While the Islanders could go on a tremendous run, the most feasible situation is grabbing the final spot in the Metro.

The reason for that lies in the standings themselves.

The defending Stanley Cup champs, the Carolina Hurricanes, are running away with the division. Entering Wednesday night’s action, the Canes sit atop the Metro with 34 points. That’s four points clear of the second-place New Jersey Devils, and 10 up on the Islanders.

Again, nothing is cast in stone. The Canes could suddenly see the wheels fall off their wagon. The Devils, for their part, could see their season fall into oblivion. But let’s get real for a minute. What are the probabilities of something like that actually happening?

The fact of the matter is that the Islanders’ only real shot is third in the Metro. The Rangers have done very well to hold on after the catastrophic injury to Igor Shesterkin. The Blueshirts have gotten some shaky goaltending at times, but their overall play has withstood the loss of their franchise goalie.

The big question at this point will be just how sustainable the Rangers’ play really is. The team got off to a hot start, but after losing Shesterkin, things haven’t really been the same.

Before losing Shesterkin on October 9, the Rangers were 5-2-0 and jockeying for position with the Hurricanes atop the Metro. Following Shesterkin’s departure, the Blueshirts went 1-3-1. Things have stabilized since, with New York winning six of their last seven games.

That situation, nonetheless, has depended on rookie Dylan Garand playing well and backup Joonas Korpisalo pretty much being the go-to guy after he returned from injury.

Could Isles overtake Rangers in the Metro Division?

So, the biggest question would have to be: Could the Islanders overtake the Rangers in the Metro Division?

The answer is absolutely yes.

The Isles have a much more balanced lineup even without the numerous injuries that have befallen the club. Getting Mathew Barzal back has been a major boost to the team. Meanwhile, Ilya Sorokin continues to be lights-out, with Schaefer, Bo Horvat, and the supporting cast pulling as much of their weight as they can.

While the Islanders have hardly been perfect, NHL betting sites are beginning to believe they can make it to the playoffs.

While the current Stanley Cup odds don’t necessarily show the Islanders as favorites to win it all, the belief has to be that once in the postseason, the Islanders are the sort of team that can do a heck of a lot of damage.

Even if the Isles are destined for a first-round matchup against Connor Hellebuyck and the Devils, it won’t matter. Hellebuyck hasn’t exactly been a standout playoff performer. And in a postseason series, anything can happen.

The other path is not friendly for the Isles

The other path available to the Islanders in the Eastern Conference is claiming a wild card spot.

That’s a much more complex proposition considering the amount of competition in the Atlantic Division.

As it stands, the Boston Bruins and the Florida Panthers, both in the Atlantic Division, hold the two wild card spots with 27 points apiece. The Islanders are actually right behind them with 24 points. That’s the same gap as the Rangers currently hold on the Isles.

But you have to think that neither the Bruins nor the Panthers could fall apart like the Rangers. Perhaps there might be a case for Florida to run out of steam at some point this season. They’ve been getting some iffy goaltending, and their mostly veteran team has shown some cracks and injury issues.

However, that might not necessarily be the case for the Bruins. The club has been playing well, and boasts three superstar players in Charlie McAvoy, Jeremy Swayman, and captain David Pastrnak. If Boston can keep their current trajectory, they may even unseat one of the current top three in the Atlantic.

And so, the Islanders may have to compete with the Montreal Canadiens, or even the Buffalo Sabres, in addition to the Panthers, for the two wild card spots.

Can the Isles overtake any of the aforementioned Atlantic Division clubs? Absolutely. The Islanders are just as good as the Sabres, Canadiens, and Panthers. The difference, nevertheless, might come down to getting a few lucky bounces here and there throughout the season, the kind of uncertainty a current prediction market betting guide frames as a chance, not a sure thing.  

If those bounces can translate into some extra points, there might just be another path forward.

Isles also have to contend with other Metro Division rivals for wild card spots

It’s also worth pointing out that the Islanders would have to contend with other Metro Division rivals for those wild card spots in the East. The Washington Capitals and potentially the Philadelphia Flyers could make up some ground as the season progresses.

Yes, the Flyers are still a mess and figure to be stuck in neutral all season. But the Capitals have to be the most intriguing team of all. They were on the cusp of making the postseason last year. They revamped their lineup and looked good on paper. They have been getting some wins, even with Alexander Ovechkin struggling. If Ovechkin can regain his form and turn things up a notch, the Caps might become another serious contender, both for the wild card and third in the Metro.

So, what does this all mean for the Islanders? Well, the path forward is simple. The only thing the Isles can really do is just win hockey games. It doesn’t matter what other teams do. As long as the Isles do their thing, they can win hockey games and let the rest sort itself out.

Add us as a preferred source on Google