The New York Islanders are on a nice point streak right now while being replenished with a slew of healthy forwards. Mathew Barzal is getting acclimated to Peter DeBoer's system. What remains constant is the leadership and star power of second-year defenseman Matthew Schaefer.
DeBoer relies on his defensive system. This has been the most obvious personnel change since Patrick Roy was let go. The blue line has seen a mix of newly acquired veterans and youth throughout the pre-season and the regular season. The most impactful addition has been Logan Stanley.
Scott Mayfield has been the odd man out this season, getting scratched for the 14th time in Winnipeg on Thursday. Clearly, DeBoer likes a style and will not give a player minutes because of tenure or past success. Many of the fans are particularly happy about that.
Still, DeBoer has leaned heavily on Schaefer, and it is not sustainable. A popular example was the 19-year-old playing the entire 5-minute overtime in a victory against Nashville. As fun as Schaefer has been, he is still a human being who needs to take care of his body for the present and future.
The Islanders sit just 2 points back of a Wild Card spot and third place in the Metropolitan Division. Schaefer is averaging over 26 minutes a game, up a whole minute from last season. I believed Roy also overused Schaefer last season to save his own job, but failed.
Schaefer has played over 30 minutes in a game 4 times this season and 5 times in the calendar year, most recently on the West Coast trip against the San Jose Sharks. Naturally, being able to contribute on special teams will boost Schaefer's minutes, but someone else will need to pick up the slack, as this is not a team that will be vying for a Stanley Cup in June.
The former first overall draft choice has plenty of hockey left in the 2026-27 season and his Islanders career. As much as he brings to the ice and the organization when he plays a lot, the minutes will need to be picked up by others, or this team cannot sustain success.
