The New York Islanders made the right call in keeping three 1st round picks

The New York Islanders made the right call by keeping all three first-round picks in their possession.

Heading into Friday night’s first-round event, speculation surrounding the Isles suggested the club would use the two picks it acquired from the Montreal Canadiens to move up and take hometown prospect James Hagens.

Hagens eventually went to the Boston Bruins at No. 7, leaving the Islanders free to use their picks.

Those picks, well, turned out to be fantastic. The Isles got Viktor Eklund at #16 and Kashawn Aitcheson at #17.

Elite Prospects describes Eklund as a “two-way forward” and a “workhorse.” He’s the sort of prospect the Islanders need to provide some much-needed balance in the club’s middle six.

As for Aitcheson, the Islanders get a second, high-end blue liner in the 2025 NHL Draft. Elite Prospects describes him as a “two-way defenseman” and a “heavy hitter.” Those adjectives aren’t necessarily synonymous, but they sound good when applied to the same player.

All in all, Isles’ GM Mathieu Darche hit a grand slam. He not only got the best player in the 2025 NHL Draft, but he also walked away with two players who could easily be the best prospects in any other organization.

While trading away Noah Dobson stung, Darche should be indicted for grand larceny. He took the Montreal Canadiens’ picks and transformed them into a coup for the Islanders.

New York Islanders prospect cupboard fully stocked

The New York Islanders’ prospect cupboard went from being relatively barren to overflowing with young talent.

The Islanders landed a high-end center in Calum Ritchie at the trade deadline this past season. Then, previous draft selections like Cole Eiserman look like a solid addition waiting to make the team.

Now, the Islanders have a replacement for Dobson in Matthew Schaefer. In my 30+ years of watching hockey, I can say that Schaefer looks like the real deal. He reminds me of Paul Coffey way back in the day during his Edmonton Oilers and Pittsburgh Penguins heyday.

Then, adding Eklund and Aitcheson all of a sudden makes the Islanders look like a team that can contend for years to come.

As exciting as adding three high-end players is, the reality is they won’t likely impact the club next season. So, it will be a matter of patience as the Islanders’ newest prospects make it through the system and make a significant impact a the NHL level.