MINUS
The clear downside to Lee is apparent declining production. Lee’s points totals have trended downward since 2017-18 when he notched a career-high 62 points. While he’s consistently maintained a 20-goal pace, there’s concern that his production may continue to decline.
Specifically, being bumped to a bottom-six role could further hamper his ability to generate offense. Then again, playing against a different set of opponents could boost Lee’s scoring chances. As a top-six forward, Lee would face the opposition’s best defenders. In a third-line role, Lee could face the opposition’s less talented defenders, allowing him to score more often.
Now, this assumption is not about sheltering Lee so that he has an easier time. It’s about helping build his confidence while providing valuable depth scoring. That’s something the New York Islanders have lacked over the last couple of seasons.
Assuming that the top six can carry their offensive weight, having a reliable third-line scoring option, while playing a responsible defensive role, should boast well for the Islanders’ overall structure and performance. Nevertheless, the fact that Lee is 34, and one more season removed from free agency, may place additional pressure on him to perform.
While it’s way too soon to talk about contract extensions for Lee, it’s undeniable that Lee must demonstrate that he still has enough gas in the tank to be a serviceable NHL forward. Otherwise, the sun may be setting on Lee’s tenure in New York.
The Verdict
Lee is part of the New York Islanders’ heart and soul. His contributions cannot go unnoticed, even if they don’t get much attention. However, Lee must find a way to recover his offensive production as the Isles look to compete in the Metro Division.
Given the strength of divisional opponents, and the overall talent level in the Eastern Conference, Anders Lee and the Islanders will need to rally together to make headway in 2024-25.